Apply academic evidence rules
Use this policy when the article review must separate verified claims, unsupported claims, citation gaps, missing evidence, and confidence.
Prompt Template
Review claim support, citation coverage, argument flow, and overclaim risk.
Back to Prompt TemplatesUse this prompt to turn an academic or research article draft into a structured evidence, citation, argument, and writing-quality review.
Use when
Use it when the draft contains factual claims, research claims, technical claims, citations, argumentation, or academic framing that must be checked before publication.
Copy the prompt and replace the MATERIALS block with the draft article, cited sources, notes, and review constraints.
Run an academic article draft review.
TASK:
Review the supplied article draft for:
- claim support
- citation coverage
- unsupported or overstated claims
- unclear argument flow
- weak structure
- academic register issues
- missing evidence
- revision actions needed before publication
REVIEW SCOPE:
Focus on the supplied draft and supplied evidence.
Use external sources only when they are supplied or when browsing is explicitly allowed.
Do not perform a full literature review unless the user explicitly asks for one.
Do not rewrite the full article unless the user explicitly asks for a rewrite.
EVIDENCE RULES:
- Do not invent sources, citations, quotes, findings, author intent, publication requirements, or factual support.
- Treat every factual, technical, scholarly, or research claim as unsupported unless the supplied materials or verified sources support it.
- If a claim is plausible but not supported, mark it as NOT VERIFIED.
- If required evidence is missing, write: INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE: <specific missing evidence>.
- If browsing is required but not available or not allowed, state what cannot be verified.
- Keep verified findings separate from missing evidence.
REVIEW CHECKS:
- Thesis clarity
- Section structure
- Claim-to-evidence alignment
- Citation coverage
- Overclaiming or unsupported inference
- Terminology precision
- Academic register
- Paragraph flow
- Redundancy or unclear transitions
- Required revisions before publication
OUTPUT:
A) Article review summary
B) Verified strengths
C) Required revisions
D) Unsupported or overclaimed points
E) Citation and evidence gaps
F) Structure and argument-flow issues
G) Academic register and clarity issues
H) Optional improvements
I) Missing evidence
J) Confidence
MATERIALS:
"""
Replace this block with:
- the draft article
- cited sources or reference list
- source excerpts or links
- publication target or audience
- required citation style, if relevant
- constraints on what may or may not be rewritten
"""
Provide the draft article and any sources, notes, citation list, publication target, or review constraints that should be used. The prompt should not invent missing sources, claims, citations, or author intent.